| Basketball |
| 1951 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1955 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1956 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1957 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1958 |
State Catholic Runner-up |
| 1959 |
State Catholic Runner-up |
| 1961 |
State Catholic Runner-up |
| 1964 |
Girls Allied Basketball Champions |
| 1969 |
Richmond City-Wide Tournament Champions |
| |
State Independent Champions |
| 1971 |
Richmond City-Wide Tournament Champions |
| 1972 |
Richmond City-Wide Tournament Champions |
| 1973 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1974 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1975 |
State Catholic Champions |
| |
JV-1st place Girls Allied Basketball Tournament |
| 1976 |
State Catholic Runner-up |
| 1977 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1978 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1980 |
Carlisle Tip-Off Champions |
| 1981 |
State Catholic Runner-up |
| |
Trinity Christmas Tournament Champions |
| 1982 |
Trinity Christmas Tournament Champions |
| 1986 |
State Catholic Runner-up |
| 1987 |
State Catholic Runner-up |
| 1993 |
LIS Champions |
| 1996 |
LIS Champions |
| 1997 |
LIS Champions |
| |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1998 |
LIS Champions |
| |
JV-Gator Invitational Champions |
| |
Virginia Independent Schools Basketball Assoc. Runner-up |
| |
All-LIS Player |
| |
All-State Player |
| 1999 |
LIS Champions |
| 2001 |
Virginia Independent Schools Basketball Assoc. Runner-up |
| |
All-LIS Player |
| |
All-State Player |
| 2002 |
VES Holiday Tournament Champions |
| 2005 |
JV White - Lady Sabre Classic Champions |
| |
2 All-LIS Players |
| |
1 All-State Player |
| 2006 |
Steward Invitational Champions |
| 2007 |
Steward Invitational Champions |
| |
|
| Field Hockey |
| 1972 |
Undefeated season |
| 2003 |
Steward Invitational - 3rd Place |
| |
|
| Golf |
| 2007 |
Undefeated Season |
| |
|
| Track |
| 1994 |
Acca Relays - Runner-up |
| 1995 |
State Catholic Champions |
| |
Benedictine Relays - Runner-up |
| |
|
| Swimming |
| 1994 |
VSIS Sportsmanship Award |
| 2004 |
All-State Swimmer |
| 2005 |
All-State Swimmer |
| 2006 |
All-State Swimmer |
| |
|
| Softball |
| 1985 |
LIS Champions |
| 1990 |
LIS Champions |
| 1997 |
LIS Champions |
| 1998 |
LIS Champions |
| 2001 |
LIS Champions |
| |
|
| Tennis |
| 1992 |
State Catholic Champions |
| 1993 |
State Catholic Champions |
| |
|
| Soccer |
| 2000 |
RISOA Sportsmanship Award |
| |
Ukrops/Central VA Festival Champion, White Division |
| 2001 |
RISOA Sportsmanship Award |
| 2002 |
Ukrops/Central VA Festival Champion, Blue Division |
| 2003 |
Gator Invitational Champions |
| 2006 |
#6 in final State Poll |
| |
2-All-LIS Players |
| |
2 All-State Players |
| 2007 |
#5 in final State Poll |
| |
4 All-LIS Players |
| |
3 All-Metro, Second Team Player |
| |
3 All-State Players |